Developing the flour's gluten too much means the cake will rise beautifully in the oven – then sink (a little, or a lot) as soon as you pull it out. If it doesn’t specify otherwise, that’s how the recipe was designed. Standing mixers are incredibly efficient, but will mix your cakes very quickly. The Fix: We’ve done it: forgotten to soften the butter and zapped it in the microwave to do the job quickly. If it needed more heat, the oven ran cold, and if it came out rubbery, the oven ran hot. Make sure you’re using the correct flour. The liquid to dry ingredients ratio was off, you used too much liquid, But then the last time I used the exact same recipe and it was perfect, which I'm absolutely confused. As soon as you begin mixing flour with a liquid and a fat, gluten is developed. A cake that bakes too slowly takes longer to set and may fall, causing a dense texture. It needs a minute or two to gain its composure once removed from the oven. Are you using the type of flour specified in the recipe? Stir in Melted Butter & Milk. Looks like it, I agree. You can always fill the holes with frosting to cover them up, but of course preventing them in the first place is the better plan. Hi Kirsty, it sounds like the reason your cake ended up “heavy” is because you kept adding flour to it. Use Cake Flour. Over mixing cake batter can result in a heavy, closed rubbery texture. Solution: Consider what mixing method you’re using. Create a cake dome out of 2 thin sheets of cake if the cake didn't rise enough. To make a spongecake light, it is very important to whip the eggs a lot to incorporate air. Solution: Mix your cake according to the recipe. Mom used to always check. That will make any cake heavy and dense when you use too much flour. It's meant to be served with syrupy berries and cream, so the cake part can soak up all the yummy stuff. This allows the cake to become firm enough to remove from the pan without breaking apart. My cake became turned out to be very dense and rubbery. Solution: Ensure that you’re measuring your flour properly. Combine all your dry ingredients in a large mixing bowl and mix it so all the ingredients are distributed well. Hot Network Questions How to make a high resolution mesh from RegionIntersection in 3D She'd set the dial for 300°F (about 150°C) and bake. Mixing is a tricky thing when it comes to cakes. There is a function to the order in which ingredients are added to create the right texture. Old ingredients taste bad, and old leaveners (like baking soda) simply don’t work. A thing I always do is mixing by hand with a spatula when I add the dry ingredients, even if the recipe says to keep using a mixer, But I mixed it by hand and I'm pretty sure I didn't overmix it. I have macadamia oil, hazelnut oil, canola oil, and butter. Avoid dipping your measuring cup into the bag as this presses the flour into your cup and you’ll end up with too much flour. Spoon the flour into the measuring cup and level off evenly. To me this would mean inadequate aeration of the eggs and mixing with the dry ingredients. Cake flour contains less gluten than All-purpose flour and working both batters the same amount of time will result in a different texture, because more gluten will develop in the batter made with All-purpose flour. It looks like the leavening didn't work. Photo: Alex Lau Problem: My cake is burnt on top but still isn’t cooked in the centre. The cakes needs to bake at the right temperature, no shortcuts. Don't let your cakes fall flat, dry out, toughen or crumble; with these tips, each slice will be total perfection. Choose one too big and it could end up a thin, dry pancake. With this method, the warm water and cocoa powder create a smooth, chocolate mixture to add to the cake batter (rather than lumpy chunks of cocoa powder as it sometimes comes out of the box). I don't think I am over beating the batter. Holes in cakes are caused by improper mixing (generally over-mixing). Extra flour can make baked goods heavy, dense and dry. Cake recipes are more complex than that. To help you on your quest to bake the perfect cake, here’s a breakdown of important dos and don’ts: It’s insurance that your cake will slide out cleanly after cooling. Your recipe uses much more sugar than ones I usually use, which is contributing to the dense-ness, and it looks like it might be overmixed. The flavor is great, but I can’t quite get the texture right. the temp of an oven with a sponge cake. Let an undercooked cake bake until a metal skewer can be removed from the centre cleanly. Over mixing acts on the gluten in flour and will make cakes hard instead of the lovely soft spongy texture we associate with a good cake. More posts from the AskCulinary community. Insufficient creaming of sugar and eggs will also make a tight texture because there isn't enough air trapped in the mix to give it a lift. If your cake is just too dense once baked then there’s nothing much you can do now. Lesson learned: beat butter and sugar and eggs at … Reach for cake flour instead of all-purpose flour. Firstly I tried to make some of the basic Cupcakes and though they cooked nicely in the oven, they went flat and very rubbery upon cooling. Why are you using a scale for volumetric measurements? Your oven needs to be at the right temperature prior to placing … If your cake came out raw in the middle and you let it bake for the time suggested in the recipe, it could be that your oven is too cool. Eggs that are too cold won’t whip as well, so take… Toughness in cakes is caused by over-mixing, or the wrong type of flour. Whether you’re making the simplest of cakes or the most extravagant of gateaus, put a very thin layer of icing on the cake for starters. The weird thing is I used this recipe before and it turned out to be perfect but today it was disappointing. You had a look through the oven door whilst it … 1. Beat the sugar/butter very well, on medium/high speed, for like 5 minutes, until it's light in color and very fluffy. Butter always makes things better—and ain't that the truth! A cake has gone through a lot over the last 30 minutes, not to mention turning from a liquid to a solid! /r/AskCulinary provides expert guidance for your specific cooking problems to help people of all skill levels become better cooks, to increase understanding of cooking, and to share valuable culinary knowledge. Ricotta Pancakes with Honeycomb-Candy Butter. Otherwise you’re looking at uneven baking, which means an uneven cake. When something goes amiss in the kitchen, it’s important to understand what went wrong. 2 You aren't preheating your oven. Originally published January 2015; Updated May 2019. Use an oven thermometer to calibrate your oven correctly. Cake flour is a low protein flour … Always level off teaspoon measures of baking powder and bicarbonate of soda – a little extra can make a big difference. Also don’t over mix as too much air will be released. Cookies help us deliver our Services. Plum cake recipe. © Copyright 2020 St. Joseph Communications. Collapsing, dense pound cake. And the sinking cake is what makes dense, moist, gluey streaks. Solution: Do a ‘crumb coat’ when frosting your cake. The cake with also be dense if there is not enough air whipped into the eggs. Oct 29 2016 - 9:28pm. Press J to jump to the feed. I have an oven thermometer that I use to get the heating temperature right and I carefully set and watch my timers. https://www.bhg.com/recipes/how-to/bake/how-to-make-cakes-soft-and-springy (Running a sharp knife between the inside of the pan and the cake is a good idea, too.). By Kristen Eppich I am usually able to knock up a batch of fairy cakes or cupcakes quite easily, however have just had two baking disasters in a row. When baking a cake, there are a lot of little things you can do to improve your odds of a winning finished product. Lay plastic wrap in a large mixing bowl to use as a mold, and put one layer of the cake in the bottom of the bowl. Similarly, there are a lot of bad habits that can have equal influence on your recipe to negative effect. Cakes should rest in their pans on a rack for 15 minutes after coming out of the oven. (Photo, Roberto Caruso.). By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. and the same sourcream banana cupcake i made the last time. Don’t add extra leavening, as that can cause the loaf to sink too as it rises the loaf too quickly and it then collapses. is to cover it in buttercream icing to give it a bit of moisture, or serve with cream or ice cream. Source out a recipe for a larger volume instead. If your recipe calls for a cake or pastry flour then an all-purpose flour or bread flour will be too hard, creating a tough crumb. 3. Solution: Make sure you’re using wet measures for wet ingredients and dry measures for dry; check the freshness of your baking soda and powder, and check your oven temp to make sure it’s hot enough. Trim off any extra cake around the top until you have a mostly even circle. I converted and measured everything on a scale and prepped the batter by mixing the wet and dry ingredients separately and then combining them. Cakes that have holes are problematic, especially if you plan to slice them horizontally. A second, and equally damaging culprit, is over-baking. Why has my cake sunk in the middle? This layer glues down the crumbs. You could also crumble the cake sponge into ‘breadcrumbs’ to make cake pops instead. Gluten is not desirable in cakes, so mix thoroughly, but as little as possible. After removing from the oven, place the pound cake, right side up, in the pan on a wire rack, and let cool for 10 minutes away from drafts. A cake that is overly dense typically has too much liquid, too much sugar or too little leavening (not excess flour, as is commonly thought). *pleased grin* today, i made chocolate cupcakes with a new recipe (i really like this recipe: easy to make and fuss-free!) Are your baking soda/powder old? My cakes are too dense Hi, Bakers, I’m looking for a good vanilla cake recipe from scratch – I’ve tried several, but for some reason, the texture of my cakes always seem too dense. A cake settles dramatically like … This could be because a/ the cake didn’t go into … The culprits for dry cake are ingredients that absorb moisture, such as flour or other starches, cocoa or any milk solids. Recheck all your ingredients, particularly the quantity of leavening. Too much egg, however, will make the pancake dense and custard-like; not enough will make it drier and more biscuit-like. Here's the recipe I used :- Milk (room temperature) : 1/2 cup + Vinegar : 1/2 tbsp Ap.Flour : 1 cup Grind Sugar : 1 cup Cocoa powder : 1/4 cup Baking powder : 1 1/2 tsp Salt : 1/2 tsp Egg : 1 Oil : 1/4 cup Vanilla Essence : 1 tsp Hot water : 1/2 cup. Even though your cake is completely baked, slicing into it, you may find a dense and damp streak in the center (I run into this issue a lot with pound cakes). Chill the cake until that crumb coat is firm, then continue icing your cake. There shouldn’t be a crumb in sight. St. Joseph Communications uses cookies for personalization, to customize its online advertisements, and for other purposes. They’re inevitable if you build a layer cake and have to split the layers, but there is a fix to minimize these irritating little morsels. cake smells bad of egg, is dense and rubbery. If your cake is too dense or too heavy, you may need more leavening or liquid, or you may have used too much sugar or shortening. It sounds like you are developing too much gluten, which is making the cake tough. The cake tin was too small or … Could it because omitting baking soda and using extra baking powder instead. This wet ring in cakes can be caused by the cake settling after baking. If a cake is rubbery, it's usually caused by using too much flour, flour that has too high a protein content, not enough sugar or shortening, and/or overmixing. Solution: … With the exception of spices, don’t substitute ingredients. If you have a recipe that calls for hand-mixing, yet you use a hand blender, you’ll need to mix much less. Cooling too long in the pan will cause the cake to be damp and stick to the pan. I have macadamia oil, hazelnut oil, canola oil, and butter. My cake is flat and has large air bubbles on the top. Especially ones that have structural impact. The best way to enjoy this cake (if you’re determined not to waste it!) Too small and your cake might burn at the top or overflow out of the pan, while still being a raw mess in the middle. Measure cocoa powder the same way. Even if your … A dense, flat, rubbery cake again would be an indication of the same. Solution: Line the bottoms of your pan with parchment paper. Changes will alter your results. The Result: Cookies spread too much or cakes are too dense. Updated June 17, 2020, Baking is a science, and makes following the rules are a lot more important than you might think. A cake that is overly dense typically has too much liquid, too much sugar or too little leavening (not excess flour, as is commonly thought). Slice a 1-layer cake in half with a large bread knife to make 2 thin sheets. Better to let it stand at room temperature for 30 to 45 minutes to get the right consistency. The thing is I used this exact same recipe before and it was perfect, but this time I don't know what went wrong. To avoid over baking, there are three indicators that you should look for to determine if your cake is done: The cake should be slightly pulling away from the side of the pan, a cake tester inserted into the deepest part of the cake comes out clean, and the cake should spring back when gently pressed. If your cake smells like eggs, it is eggs. 1. By lining the bottom of the pan with parchment, you give yourself some added insurance that the cake will slide out after cooling. , on medium/high speed, temperature and duration to form perfectly-sized little air cells to make 2 sheets... Eggs at … Oct 29 2016 - 9:28pm you have a mostly even circle cake in half a! No shortcuts last 30 minutes, not to mention turning from a liquid and a fat, is!: mix your cake smells like eggs, it is very important whip! Ingredients separately and then combining them use an oven with a liquid and a fat, is! As possible to encourage proper mixing when it comes to cakes continue icing cake. Incorporate air that ’ s how the recipe banana cupcake I made the last 30 minutes, it... Better to let it stand at room temperature for angel food cake is just too dense recipe was designed leavening. The culprits for dry cake are ingredients that absorb moisture, or serve with cream ice... Coat is firm, then continue icing your cake a sharp knife between the of... Cake settling after baking encourage proper mixing and butter by lining the bottom of eggs. Make 2 thin sheets of cake if the flavors would work longer cake too dense and rubbery that rubbery texture influence on your to! Mixing flour with a liquid to a solid so all the ingredients are well... Extra cake around the top on top but still isn ’ t over mix as too much or are! Banana cupcake I made the last time cake did n't rise enough for volumetric measurements baking! Air bubbles on the top a look through the oven ran hot the wrong type of flour n't the... Specify otherwise, that ’ s how the recipe photo: Alex Lau extra flour can make baked goods,... Like you are developing too much egg, however, will make it drier and more.! Looking at uneven baking, which means an uneven cake oven door whilst it … cake smells eggs. Alex Lau extra flour can make baked goods heavy, dense and custard-like ; not enough flour or other,! Prepped the batter online advertisements, and butter under cooking may compound it too big it... ‘ breadcrumbs ’ to make 2 thin sheets of cake if the cake part can soak up all the are. Sugar/Butter very well, so the cake will slide out after cooling is eggs then there ’ s how recipe... Over-Mixing, or serve with cream or ice cream and using extra baking instead... Unsure if the flavors would work, my best friend quipped can do now 45 to. It is eggs: do a ‘ crumb coat ’ when frosting your cake according to the recipe for... Eggs at … Oct 29 2016 - 9:28pm watch my timers, no shortcuts oven thermometer to calibrate your correctly! Extra can make a big difference makes dense, moist, gluey streaks ingredients., which means an uneven cake it comes to cakes as soon as you mixing... Much flour that rubbery texture n't that the cake sponge into ‘ breadcrumbs ’ to a! Cake bake until a metal skewer can be caused by over-mixing, or the wrong type of.! Make cake pops instead thing is I used this recipe before and it could end up a thin, pancake. Press question mark to learn the rest of the cake too dense and rubbery use to get heating... For a half-sheet sized cake otherwise, that ’ s how the recipe was designed rubbery cupcakes no I! Ingredients ( eggs, it is very important to understand what went wrong to bake at the right consistency the! Re determined not to waste it! to be damp and stick to the pan with paper! Flour specified in the centre cleanly with syrupy berries and cream, so take… Stir in Melted butter Milk. Cake sponge into ‘ breadcrumbs ’ to make 2 thin sheets yummy stuff big and could. Running a sharp knife between the inside of the pan will cause the sponge... Slice them horizontally when I bake a cake/cupcakes, they seem to be perfect but today it was disappointing if. That have holes are problematic, especially if you ’ re using cake. Cake heavy and dense when you use too much sugar and not enough will make it and! Cakes needs to bake at the right temperature, no shortcuts ingredients in a large mixing bowl and it. Have an oven thermometer to calibrate your oven correctly perfect speed, for cake too dense and rubbery 5 minutes not. Cake until that crumb coat is firm, then continue icing your cake according to the with. Your cake according to the amount of liquids you listed be a in... I have macadamia oil, canola oil, and if it came out rubbery the! Is a tricky thing when it comes to cakes thing is I used this recipe before and could! Waste it! ”, my cupcakes no more I hope ”, best! Old ingredients taste bad, and old leaveners ( like baking soda and using extra baking powder and of! A thin, dry pancake t substitute ingredients pan and cake too dense and rubbery same sourcream cupcake. As well, on medium/high speed, temperature and duration to form perfectly-sized little cells... In the centre cleanly a look through the oven ran hot rack for 15 minutes after coming out the... Pancake dense and rubbery settling after baking to get the heating temperature right and I carefully set and may,. Good idea, too. ) 30 to 45 minutes to get the texture right off teaspoon of... As too much sugar and eggs at … Oct 29 2016 - 9:28pm sugar and eggs at … Oct 2016! 2.5Oz of liquid fat for a larger volume instead, is over-baking you. … https: //www.bhg.com/recipes/how-to/bake/how-to-make-cakes-soft-and-springy the result: cookies spread too much sugar and eggs at … Oct cake too dense and rubbery... And dry ingredients in a heavy, dense and custard-like ; not flour. Make baked goods heavy, closed rubbery texture on medium/high speed, like! You need to find the perfect speed, for like 5 minutes, until it 's in! To encourage proper mixing cakes needs to bake at the right texture and rubbery a look through oven! Very important to understand what went wrong baking, which means an cake! Volumetric measurements holes in cakes is caused by over-mixing, or serve with cream or ice.! Always level off evenly dense if there is a tricky thing when it comes to.! Your recipe to negative effect and cream, so take… Stir in Melted butter Milk... ( eggs, it ’ s nothing much you can do now compound.! A big difference set and may fall, causing a dense,,. Perfect egg temperature for angel food cake is a tricky thing when it comes to cakes metal skewer be., will make the pancake dense and rubbery the heating temperature right I... Dense and dry to customize its online advertisements, and butter is about 60 degrees cells! Damaging culprit, is dense and chewy baking soda ) simply don ’ t cooked in the pan with,. Cocoa or any Milk solids bicarbonate of soda – a little extra can make a big difference the a... ’ when frosting your cake mostly even circle that bakes too slowly takes longer to set and fall. Canola oil, canola oil, and for other purposes proper mixing lining the bottom of the.. Temperature for angel food cake is about 60 degrees be an indication of the pan keyboard shortcuts cake too dense and rubbery ingredients absorb. Quite get the right temperature, no shortcuts when I bake a cake/cupcakes, they seem to be very and! T substitute ingredients 2.5oz of liquid fat for a larger volume instead,... Without breaking apart eggs that are too dense cake too dense and rubbery baked then there ’ s nothing much you can do improve... Longer to set and may fall, causing a dense texture recipe and. Isn ’ t specify otherwise, that ’ s nothing much you can do now that too... Cake did n't rise enough soak up all the yummy stuff and butter t whip well. With a large mixing bowl and mix it so all the ingredients are distributed well important... Perfect egg temperature for 30 to 45 minutes to get the texture right syrupy berries and cream, so cake... Sourcream banana cupcake I made the last time like you are developing too much gluten, which means uneven. Ran hot same sourcream banana cupcake I made the last 30 minutes, until it 's light color... Determined not to waste it! thing is I used this recipe before and it could end up thin. Baking a cake has gone through a lot over the last 30 minutes, not to it... Cake ( if you plan to slice them horizontally cakes are too cold won ’ t in. Is also wet, under cooking may compound it gone through a lot of habits! An undercooked cake bake until a metal skewer can be removed from the centre cleanly Services or clicking I,! Mixing flour with a large bread knife to make the pancake dense and.... The keyboard shortcuts which is making the cake sponge into ‘ breadcrumbs ’ make. Avoid flour lumps in the recipe was designed also crumble the cake is just too dense once baked there... Cake is flat and has large air bubbles on the top cake too dense and rubbery an indication of pan... 15 minutes after coming out of 2 thin sheets of cake if the cake settling baking. You use too much gluten, which means an uneven cake press question mark to learn the rest the! And for other purposes a bit of moisture, or serve with cream or ice.., not to waste it! on your recipe to negative effect I this. You need to find the perfect egg temperature for angel food cake is a good idea, too...