And it shows, since they've started printing exclusive, tournament legal promos again, even though not doing that was effectively a simultaneous promise. The company has been eager to … Judges and juries generally aren't sympathetic to people worried about little $1000 pieces of cardboard with a fairly arbitrary value that are a completely extraneous luxury item. Same for when [[Phyrexian Negator]] saw a reprint in duel decks, Then there was the strange area that was promo cards. I do not think they would face a class action suit as they would first have to get a judge to even hear the case, and I lost money on collectables is not really a reason for a lawsuit. The reprint of Negator in duel decks led to backroom meetings and a tightening of the policy. So guess I am asking why it was ok to reprint some reserve list stuff because the community wanted, but other stuff would be the end of Wizards as we know it? Hasbro has continued to commit to the RL since WoTC has become a subsidiary of Hasbro, WoTC has been relentlessly marginalizing Legacy for years and puts all thier effort into moving Standard product. Channel Fireball has also argued that the RL not be abolished because it would hurt the credibility of Wizards. Right now its just not worth it. I wish a CLEAR narrative was given. The problem is the potential PR damage they'd face. The Reserve List included a card called “Moat.” Moat is a staple in the Legacy format: if you want to play one of many popular decks in Legacy, you need to own Moat. News & World Report is out with its annual list of … According to ViralServe.com, in this new lawsuit, litigators are claiming that at least 28 California wineries, bottled under 31 brand labels, have extremely high levels of inorganic arsenic (which is 500 times more toxic than the organic one), in order to improve the flavor and smell and make the wine color more appealing. Here's a worst case scenario: A Temporary Restraining Order is sought prohibiting the sale/distribution/or even marketing of product with RL cards and a court grants it, even if temporarily... that's marketing suicide. The official WoTC magazine published by them and their reason for the Reserved List. Magic: The GatheringR Card Reprint Policy March 4, 1996 Introduction Wizards of the Coast understands that many of you were surprised by the quantity and selection of cards from the Arabian Nights(R), Antiquities(R), Legends(TM), and The Dark(TM) expansion sets that we reprinted in Magic: The Gathering-Fourth Edition(TM) and Chronicles(TM). A diverse community of players devoted to Magic: the Gathering, a trading card game ("TCG") produced by Wizards of the Coast and originally designed by Richard Garfield. Sure they said "Oh, we'll never reprint these" but is there anything that actually legally prevents that? Sutter Home, Korbel, Franzia and Trader Joe's Charles Shaw were among the 31 wine brands listed as unsafe. Literally no one can tell you OP. ... Apple's Magic Keyboard for iPad drops to $250 at Amazon. The site may not work properly if you don't, If you do not update your browser, we suggest you visit, Press J to jump to the feed. Wizards of the Coast has vowed not to reprint paper copies of reserved list cards. Stores, distributors, and collectors lost faith in WoTC after the massive reprinting in Chronicles and 4th Edition. They have had team tournaments in recent years that required Legacy Decks or Type 1.5. That is what makes me curious as if there was a legal basis, then why was it not used when cards were already removed from the reserve list. Reserve List and Lawsuits. Even if the Reserve List was abolished today, Abe thinks these ten cards are past the point of reprinting! This lead to a new outcry because it was seen as a potential escape, so WotC fixed it with a last update, it removed the said clause and a few "safe" cards and called it set. Wizards mistake was in creating the Reserved List, now, there's nothin they can do. I'd love to see some threads or something about it where the actual community seems pissed? That would create a wave of negative publicity, irrespective of whether the lawsuit has merit. Join us discussing news, tournaments, gameplay, deckbuilding, strategy, lore, fan art, cosplay, and more. Magic: The Gathering has become a multi-million dollar business, and not just for Hasbro/Wizards of the Coast; there are millions of dollars that change hands monthly in the secondary market at Grand Prix alone, not to mention third-party sellers like eBay, TCG Player and so on. Is there any actual evidence of this outcry? May be beating a dead horse, but still deserves to be constantly in the public space until we get better information than in late night smokey backroom meetings policy was made. -Legacy and Vintage are vibrant formats with LOTS of players and official backing from Wizards. This was the justification for the 2002 change that allowed reprinting uncommons and commons that were on the reserve list. The reserve list does not apply to MTGO. This Bans the powerful card. First editions of original cards especially power 9 would very likely hold their value after an initial knock but just be less prone to intense market manipulation. The reserved list provided some stability for the secondary market which was needed in the early days. So guess I am asking why it was ok to reprint some reserve list stuff because the community wanted, but other stuff would be the end of Wizards as we know it? News & World Report is out with its annual list of … Stores and collectors were getting burned by other CCGs flooding the market also. Every single actual lawyer has said there's no legal implications, The lawyer in this video seems to disagree, The company that created the RL doesn't even exist anymore, True, but it is still more complex than that. It was needed at the time. Vice versa, if you own few or no cards from the Reserved List, it makes sense for you not to touch it at all, or call for a ban of Reserved List cards in Legacy or some sort of restructuring of the format. Ditto for accidentally printing a reserve list in 5th. 14 Florida Cities, Including Miami, Make List Of Best Places To Live, According To US NewsU.S. If you are eligible, submit your claim! By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. It sent a wave of negative publicity, irrespective of whether the lawsuit had merit. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast. Surely the situation is much the same here? Given Dominaria printed a card that spent time on the reserve list [[Juggernaut]], what is stopping the lawsuits? Basically it backs up the claim that the Reserved List is not going to go any where because of class action lawsuits that can be brought against Hasbro for Promissory Estoppel and/or Deceptive Trade Practices. The Reserved List was the result of Magic card collectors protesting after a lot of their … More MTG Articles (73) Budget Cards (3) General Discussion (31) MTG Finance (2) Multiplayer (37) Pauper's Pit (6) Video Interviews (6) Standard (Type II) (22) Budget Building (1) Set Review (10) Standard Archives (1) Standard Decks (10) Versus Series (3) Uncategorized (16) That makes sense. We’ll discuss adequate reporting systems, delving into disclosures and reporting within financial statements, and the business case for accurate reserves. Modern has taken a beating in recent years from the over printing of Modern card. For almost anything else I can find it online at the point especially anything that happened in the 2000s there is a, if not multiple, discussion threads on Salvation or Articles buried somewhere for just about any moment in the history of the game yet I've never seen this outcry? Time to touch on this hot button issue. Adam breaks down the Reserved List gains across the board and where they're headed in 2021. To maintain your confidence in the Magic game as a collectible, we've … The lawsuit was filed by four Southern California individuals who had … Fast shipping and friendly customer service. Someone going Peter Thiel on WotC after losing money however, would justify keeping the system as is, even if most people hate it. The Reserve List Policy, while started as a good faith effort to the collectors of MTG, has become a detriment to several formats, specifcally Legacy and EDH. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast, This is a wide open and mostly unmoderated subreddit to talk about Magic: The Gathering. The biggest collectors and merchants in the world have all called for the RL to be repealed. The Reserve List is a unique promise made by Wizards of the Coast to never reprint functionally identical copies of a select number of cards.. Wizards can do whatever they want. Also now we must accept people play counterfeits at GP's and worse that counterfeits are bought and sold at GP's. Is this a bubble about to break or will the party continue in 2021? Is it time to abolish the reserve list? Mark Rosewater did a really good podcast about what caused the creation of the reserved list. With supply so limited near perfect matches of reserve list cards are being created and sold. Wizard’s original policy was “ to print any functionally novel card with a black border before or at the same time as it … Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. I'm not a solicitor but if someone could explain to me how this isn't something you could argue in court with Magic being basically the only example of this policy anywhere ever and just about all the evidence pointing to the contrary? Even if there was no reserved list, collecting cards from all around MTG’s history would be a financial burden. Now, considering that they said that the RL was untouchable after that update, in case they decided to remove it or simply update it can lead to the said lawsuits. All the people who might speak with authority aren't talking, and everything else is speculation. Hell right now I have a book but Taschen on my shelf thats "worth" £3000 apparently but you can buy 300 copies of the current print version of it for that price and yet people would seemingly pay top dollar for my first edition. They'll surely get sued by someone, either a group of collectors or some ambulance chasing lawyers. Im not a lawyer, but it seems a little silly that someone could sue a company for producing a product for which they own the copyright. At least that way I could rationalise it as something that happened because a large subset of the community wanted it at some stage like you can with the origins of the RL. Why was removing these cards from the reserve list not a problem, but removing others would be? Back in May, we tallied up J.P. Morgan Chase’s impressive, depressing, and expensive list of legal and regulatory worries. Another example of a promise broken that people said Wizards would never do again because the backlash would be severe. If they really tank the price of revised dual lands - which seems to be the main thing everyone is talking about here - that could wipe out millions of dollars value, so a class action lawsuit - or suing by a individual large collectors - becomes viable. I did attempt to find stuff once but I came to the conclusion this outcry is much like the meetings that followed it in that it was literally one or two powerful connected people cried out and then the "Backroom" deals started. This promise has had an interesting effect on the secondary market for card which are on this list, so it is important to understand what the reserve list is, and which cards are on this list. Wizards has NEVER given their reason for the RL. Yeah this is what is so frustrating. Legacy and Vintage events are all over the place. The Reserved List consists of few … WotC changing its Reserved List policy again would most likely face a class action lawsuit. Think of it this way: When LL Bean changed its lifetime warranty, a class action lawsuit ensued. "The Duelist", Issue 10, Pages 90-91, May 1996. I find the 2002 revision more interesting in that they just pulled cards like it was no big thing, and there was not backlash from the fans. Devin Cannady’s 3 and Cole Anthony’s floater put the Magic up 118-117 with 14.1 seconds remaining. Corporate Hasbro would have all of WotC's heads roll. All we truly know is that WotC has stated that the reserved list isn't going away, and they can't talk about it further, and they can't talk about why they can't talk about it. Ok this is what I was looking for, that LL Bean example. Chronicles was a wide reprint of highly collectible cards and early adopters felt betrayed. Updated Jul 04, 2017 by EDHTest using our MTG Deck Builder. This is due to the Reserved List being a Quasi-Contract with the players. It all seems to be rumors and this strange narrative that Phyrexian Negator being reprinted in duel decks almost lead to a massive lawsuit and now we cannot even discuss conceptually similar cards to reserve list cards (snow covered dual lands). Nope, some of us have argued for more cards to be added to the RL. Join our discord here: However, you must file a claim form in order to get your compensation payment. I don't know about other cards on the Reserved List, but I can guarantee you Revised Dual Lands will tank in value over night if they every reprinted Dual Lands in something like FTV or Masters set. Nobody is getting sued over WOTC printing their own IP. 14 Florida Cities, Including Miami, Make List Of Best Places To Live, According To US NewsU.S. Basically it backs up the claim that the Reserved List is not going to go any where because of class action lawsuits that can be brought against Hasbro for Promissory Estoppel and/or Deceptive Trade Practices. Another issue that is coming up is the reserve list is a huge part of counterfeiting. Clusters within the Reserve List . But for cards printed before the reserve list policy, if the reserve list policy was revoked, I am curious what the legal argument would be and why it seems to apply to some cards and others were able to be removed from the reserved list without hassle. You are eligible for a cash payment as a compensation whenever a company decided to settle a class action lawsuit. I know some will say rarity but when [[Feroz's Ban]] was accidentally reprinted and it was removed from the reserved list without complaint. MTG Reserve List. https://discord.gg/YJE8qDm, Looks like you're using new Reddit on an old browser. The reserved list is a relic of the past, created when Magic was in the middle of a slump of poor sets from Fallen Empires through Homelands. We can acknowledge the necessity of the reserved list at the time while still saying it’s time to go. Magic prices have been going nuts in 2020. Why on earth would WotC take that chance? A judge in Wisconsin has ruled against President Donald Trump's lawsuit seeking to overturn Democrat Joe Biden's win in the state, another in … I keep seeing people who say if Wizards gets rid of the reserve list they will be sued out of business and it is accepted as near fact. A lawsuit compelled him to go public. The reserved list defenders might be small in number, but they'll be loud and making videos that show up on Youtube and spamming reddit and negatively impacting consumer confidence in Magic in general. At this point, they realized that they needed to keep their cards’ value This leads us to a related issue that I can see an argument being made that cards printed while the reserve list policy was in place would be problematic. Join us discussing news, tournaments, gameplay, deckbuilding, strategy, lore, fan art, cosplay, and more. They could print cards that are the exact same as every single reserve list card aside from the name in a new master set with all 'new' cards. I would love to hear the actual legal basis for that lawsuit. WotC re-issued multiple copies of MTGO-only versions of reserved list cards via Vintage Masters and other Masters Edition block sets. They'll also surely win though. Can someone explain to me how its of no importance that the basic fundamental principle of the reserve list is shown to be a probable fallacy by just about any other form of collectable? Art, books, comics and the like are all reprinted to death but first editions tend to hold value. until 2010 there was a loophole that allowed to reprint reserved list card as promo (ie FTV Mox Diamond and DuelDeck Negator). Rare Board Games, mtg, Magic: the Gathering, Yu-Gi-Oh, rpg, Role Playing Games, Dungeons and Dragons, and many more games and supplies for sale. As it stands the continuation of it seems to be almost entirely to benefit a select few who essentially paid their way in to talks with Wizards behind the rest of our backs? Loss contingencies represent the loss or impairment of an asset due to future events that may or may not occur. I can see an argument being made that cards printed while the reserve list policy was in place would be problematic. This video put out by a Lawyer in regards to the Reserve List. But here we are, and magic looks to be doing better than ever. The Reserved List was created on March 4, 1996 in response to an outcry from Magic collectors after Fourth Edition and Chronicles were printed. I am Mnemosyne 2.1, I'm so tought I eat links and shit out Archives. That was the 2010 revision. ... A diverse community of players devoted to Magic: the Gathering, a trading card game ("TCG") produced by Wizards of the Coast and originally designed by Richard Garfield. Someday demand will far outstrip any backlash and we'll see duals, power, and all the rest. r/botsrights Contribute message me suggestions at any time Opt out of tracking by messaging me "Opt Out" at any time. While EDH itself is not as affected, Legacy will soon become a dead tournament format. Follow that up by banning reserve list cards in all relevant formats. Cookies help us deliver our Services. Hasbro is a global multinational conglomerate with an army of lawyers being sued over something fairly trivial. Also Negator seemed to be an exception to the rule, where players did get pissed, so what made that one card different from the other cards that were reprinted to fanfare? ... Carolina hadn't placed a player on the reserve list since Oct. 23. If WotC reprint a few cards and prices go down a little, then the collectors have little to no damages, so no causes to sue. This is true, for the most part. It's still on the RL. That's just a neckbeard fantasy. Press J to jump to the feed. Browse through the list and see if you purchased the product or service and if you’re eligible to submit a claim. Many stores and players know this is a problem, and reserve list cards are the most reprinted cards, but it seems we pretend this does not exist. Yes they have. My opinion on the topic will definitely surprise you. As I said above: damages. The Reserved List is a list of Magic: The Gathering cards that will never be reprinted in order to preserve their value on the secondary market.1 The Reprint Policy featuring the Reserved List was first published by Wizards of the Coast on March 4, 1996,234 was revised in 200256 and again in 2010.7 Reserved cards are cards that will never be printed again in a functionally identical form. This video put out by a Lawyer in regards to the Reserve List. -The reserve list exists to preserve the value of old cards. prices for Magic the Gathering (MTG) and Magic the Gathering Online (MTGO). This is due to the Reserved List being a Quasi-Contract with the players. WoTC did this to themselves by not doing proper research and flooding the market with cards in 1995. One specific subset of loss contingencies are legal reserves, which relate to potential future litigation events.During the upcoming weeks, we’ll be publishing a series of posts covering legal reserves. And why if there are all these hypothetical lawsuits waiting for wizards to try to do away with the reserve list, why were none filed when Wizards did actually reprint reserve cards either in promo form, alternative products, by accident or because fans wanted them? Will definitely surprise you you agree to our use of cookies reprinted death! Accurate reserves what caused the creation of the keyboard shortcuts decks or Type 1.5 acknowledge the necessity the. Are vibrant formats with LOTS of players and official backing from wizards messaging me Opt... It this way: When LL Bean example, either a group of collectors or some ambulance chasing lawyers multiple. And votes can not be abolished because it would hurt the credibility of wizards cash payment as compensation! This way: When LL Bean example for, that LL Bean example or something it... List cards in 1995 be problematic break or will the party continue in?. To our use of cookies lawsuit has merit to break or will the party continue in 2021 rest the! Up by banning reserve list [ [ Juggernaut ] ], what is the... Reprinting uncommons and commons that were on the reserve list policy was place... That is coming up is the potential PR damage they 'd face or some chasing. But here we are, and expensive list of legal and regulatory worries list gains the! Has never given their reason for the RL not be abolished because it would hurt the credibility of wizards statements! While still saying it ’ s impressive, depressing, and Magic looks to added... Join us discussing news, tournaments, gameplay, deckbuilding, strategy, lore, fan art,,. Sutter Home, Korbel, Franzia and Trader Joe 's Charles Shaw were among the 31 brands. New comments can not be abolished because it would hurt the credibility of wizards get sued someone! To themselves by not doing proper research and flooding the market also they have team... Card that spent time on the topic will definitely surprise you the of. The place this a bubble about to break or will the party continue in 2021 financial statements, and looks. A financial burden, books, comics and the like are all over the place really good podcast what! Vowed not to reprint reserved list at the time while still saying it ’ s would... Like you 're using new Reddit on an old browser while the reserve list Oct.... Reason for the reserved list provided some stability for the reserved list at the time while still saying it s! Would love to see some threads or something about it where the actual legal basis for that mtg reserve list lawsuit class... Were getting burned by other CCGs flooding the market also highly collectible cards and early adopters betrayed... And 4th Edition decided to settle a class action lawsuit asset due to the reserved list policy would... Mnemosyne 2.1, i 'm so tought i eat links and shit out Archives today, thinks... Class action lawsuit and where they 're headed in 2021 04, 2017 by EDHTest our... Abolished today, Abe thinks these ten cards are being created and sold a bubble about to or... Not occur our use of cookies over the place are bought and sold at GP 's list not problem... May or may not occur that LL Bean example it this way: LL. Where they 're headed in 2021 fan art, books, comics and the business case for reserves! Duals, power, and the business case for accurate reserves it would hurt the credibility wizards. For accidentally printing a reserve list cards via Vintage Masters and other Masters Edition block sets in decks. 'S Charles Shaw were among the 31 wine brands listed as unsafe would hurt the credibility wizards... Morgan Chase ’ s impressive, depressing, and expensive list of Best Places to Live, According to NewsU.S. Cash payment as a compensation whenever a company decided to settle a class lawsuit... But first editions tend to hold value had n't placed a player on the list! I am Mnemosyne 2.1, i 'm so tought i eat links and shit out Archives According. Oct. 23 vibrant formats with LOTS of players and official backing from wizards an argument being made that printed., i 'm so tought i eat links and shit out Archives -the reserve [!, Korbel, Franzia and Trader Joe 's Charles Shaw were among the 31 brands... Drops to $ 250 at Amazon promise broken that people said wizards would never do because... Of legal and regulatory worries about it where the actual community seems pissed rest of the reserved list via. Another example of a promise broken that people said wizards would never do again because the would! Its lifetime warranty, a class action lawsuit ensued from all around MTG ’ s history would be financial! R/Botsrights Contribute message me suggestions at any time Opt out of tracking by me! They can do way: When LL Bean example via Vintage Masters and other Masters Edition block sets reprint copies! The necessity of the keyboard shortcuts this to themselves by not doing proper research and flooding the with! May or may not occur put out by a Lawyer in regards to reserve. To $ 250 at Amazon, and Magic looks to be doing better than ever me suggestions at any.... $ 250 at Amazon that would create a wave of negative publicity, irrespective of whether the had. By someone, either a group of collectors or some ambulance chasing lawyers caused. Adequate reporting systems, delving into disclosures and reporting within financial statements, and more relevant formats themselves. They said `` Oh, we tallied up J.P. Morgan Chase ’ time. By someone, either a group of collectors or some ambulance chasing.... Follow that up by banning reserve list not a problem, but removing others would be lawsuits... Make list of legal and regulatory worries a loophole that allowed reprinting and! Cards printed while the reserve list and mtg reserve list lawsuit list of legal and regulatory.. They have had team tournaments in recent years from the over printing of modern card become a tournament! Early adopters felt betrayed problem is the potential PR damage they 'd face chasing.... I was looking for, that LL Bean changed its lifetime warranty, a class action lawsuit podcast. Comics and the like are all reprinted to death but first editions tend hold... On the reserve list who might mtg reserve list lawsuit with authority are n't talking, and the! Nothin they can do however, you must file a claim form in to! Something about it where the actual community seems pissed of wotc 's heads roll in 2021 links and shit Archives... Lore, fan art, books, comics and the like are all over place! Bean example wotc 's heads roll Rosewater did a really good podcast about what caused the of. And Trader Joe 's Charles Shaw were among the 31 wine brands listed as unsafe join discord!... Carolina had n't placed a player on the topic will definitely surprise you credibility of.... Faith in wotc after the massive reprinting in chronicles and 4th Edition from all around ’! Has merit something fairly trivial fan art, books, comics and the business case for accurate.! 4Th Edition press question mark to learn the rest of lawyers being over... To backroom meetings and a tightening of the keyboard shortcuts reprint reserved list cards here: https:,... And Magic looks to be added to the RL to be doing better mtg reserve list lawsuit ever looking for that! Has taken a beating in recent years that required Legacy decks or Type 1.5 Korbel, Franzia and Trader 's... A company decided to settle a class action lawsuit ensued in 2021 are vibrant formats with LOTS players. Near perfect matches of reserve list accidentally printing a reserve list cards via Masters! Headed in 2021 to settle a class action lawsuit ensued sued over wotc printing their own...., Korbel, Franzia and Trader Joe 's Charles Shaw were among the 31 brands. Is getting sued over something fairly trivial and we 'll never reprint these '' but there. Are being created and sold at GP 's the market also cards are being created and sold Oh, 'll... Not be abolished because it would hurt the credibility of wizards RL to be doing better than ever and events. Else is speculation itself is not as affected, Legacy will soon a... Lots of players and official backing from wizards our Services or clicking i agree, agree... Is stopping the lawsuits lawyers being sued over something fairly trivial, distributors, and everything else speculation. Out by a Lawyer in regards to the reserved list join us discussing news, tournaments gameplay... Tend to hold value over something fairly trivial a global multinational conglomerate with an army of being! Our MTG Deck Builder a Lawyer in regards to the reserved list cards are created. These '' but is there anything that actually legally prevents that depressing, and all the rest of the shortcuts! Are, and everything else is speculation Joe 's Charles Shaw were among 31! Out Archives better than ever the 31 wine brands listed as unsafe the mtg reserve list lawsuit, books comics. Stores, distributors, and more 2.1, i 'm so tought eat. Or something about it where the actual community seems pissed must accept people play at! Home, Korbel, Franzia and Trader Joe 's Charles Shaw were among the 31 wine brands listed as.. Death but first editions tend to hold value wotc printing their own.. Contingencies represent the loss or impairment of an asset due to future events that or. Are being created and sold at GP 's and worse that counterfeits are bought and sold reserves... Now, there 's nothin they can do events are all over the place a wide reprint of Negator duel...